What was an election petition? Challenging election outcomes, 1832-68


Many of our 19th-century History of Parliament biographies refer to MPs ‘being unseated on petition’ or ‘losing their seat on petition’. Dr Kathryn Rix, co-editor of our House of Commons, 1832-1945 project, explains what this process that elections petitions triggered involved, looking at the system as it operated between 1832 and 1868.

In his novel Coningsby (1844), Benjamin Disraeli featured a fictional election contest between a Conservative, Mr Rigby, and a Liberal, Mr Millbank. With 15 minutes left until polling closed, the Conservative election agent alerted Rigby to his impending defeat.

You think it’s all over then?”

Why, I do not see now how we can win. We have polled all our dead men, and Millbank is seven a-head.”

I have no doubt we shall be able to have a good petition”, said the consoling chairman of the Conservative Association.

An election petition was the means of challenging the outcome of an election. Between 1832 and 1868 almost 750 election petitions were presented to the House of Commons. Although many were based on allegations which could not be substantiated, and were subsequently withdrawn or dismissed, just over a quarter led to the unseating of an MP.

The key charges made in these petitions were that the victorious MPs owed their return to corrupt practices. The three main offences were:

  • bribery – giving or offering money or some other financial benefit
  • treating – the provision of food, drink or entertainment
  • undue influence – the use of violence or intimidation.

Following earlier legislation such as the 1696 Treating Act and the 1729 Bribery Act, the 1854 Corrupt Practices Prevention Act laid out extensive definitions of these offences.

Painting of an election scene depicting a large crowd in a street, surrounded by buildings. There is a procession with a carriage. One of the figures in the foreground is a man in a white smock who is putting money in his pocket.
Vladimir Ossipovitch Sherwood, The Preston By-Election of 1862; Parliamentary Art Collection. The man in the white smock in the foreground appears to be putting money in his pocket, suggesting he may have been bribed.

Other reasons for election petitions were to challenge the qualification of the MP or of the voters who had polled. Prior to 1858, when the property qualification for MPs was abolished, several MPs were unseated for this reason. They included William Wilberforce, son of the noted anti-slavery campaigner, and Edward Glover, whose false declaration about his qualification led to his imprisonment. In a highly unusual case, Joseph Holdsworth lost his seat on petition in 1841 because he had technically been the returning officer as well as the candidate when he was elected for Wakefield. Petitions were also presented in cases where candidates polled an equal number of votes and the returning officer made a double (or triple) return, leaving the Commons to resolve the matter.

While anyone, voter or non-voter, could sign a petition to Parliament on other subjects – such as the mass petitions for parliamentary reform organised by the Chartists – election petitions had their own rules. They had to come from someone who had the right to vote at the disputed election or someone who had been or claimed to have been a candidate. Election petitions had to be presented within fourteen days of the start of the new parliamentary session or, for by-elections, within fourteen days of the MP’s return. To prevent ‘frivolous’ or ‘vexatious’ challenges being made to election results, the petitioners had to provide sureties (‘recognizances’) of £1,000 as a guarantee that they would be able to meet the petition costs.

Extract of text from the Commons Journal 1833 with the opening words of the Hertford election petition. The text reads: A petition of Thomas Slingsby Duncombe, Esquire, of Arlington-street, in the county of Middlesex, and of John Eden Spalding, Esquire, of Eaton-place, Belgrave-square, in the county of Middlesex, was also read;
Opening lines of the petition on the Hertford election petition (Commons Journal, 1833, vol. 88, pg. 23; PD, accessed via archive.org)

Until the system changed in 1868, election petitions were presented to and handled by the Commons. Before 1770, petitions were tried by the whole House of Commons and were generally seen as an opportunity for the government to increase its majority. In 1770 the Grenville Act introduced a new format, intended to be more impartial, under which petitions were instead tried by select committees composed of a small number of MPs.

Following further reform in 1828, the system in use at the time of the 1832 Reform Act was that these select committees each had 11 members. The names of 33 MPs were drawn by lot from six ‘glasses’ in the House of Commons. The petitioners and those defending the seat then took turns to strike names off this list until only 11 remained. MPs aged over sixty could be excused from service and MPs who had petitions pending against them were ineligible to serve. As MPs had to be present in the House during this process for their name to appear on the list of 33, party whips compelled MPs to attend, which immediately gave the committees a partisan character.

There were regular calls for reform of the system, prompted by concerns not only about partisanship, but also the slow, cumbersome and expensive process of these select committee hearings. With 11 MPs serving on each case, petition trials occupied a significant amount of parliamentarians’ time at the start of each new Parliament, affecting their availability for other parliamentary duties. This was particularly problematic given the large number of petitions being presented. Forty election petitions came to trial following the 1832 election. This fell to 21 in 1835, but rose to 54 in 1837.

The process had a significant overhaul in 1839, with a new system of appointing the committees, which were also reduced in size. The Speaker was tasked with appointing six MPs to a General Committee of Elections at the start of each session. This committee was responsible for appointing select committees to try each petition. It chose a small number of more experienced MPs (between six and 12) as ‘the chairman’s panel’. Each select committee trying a petition consisted of one of these chairmen and a further six MPs. This was cut to four MPs and a chairman in 1844. However, there were still concerns that MPs’ compulsory service on election committees left them unable to contribute to other parliamentary business. Sir John Trollope, chairman of the General Committee on Elections, complained that with more than 60 petitions due for trial in the wake of the notoriously corrupt 1852 election, ‘some of the most practical and useful Members’ would be unable to attend select committees on other matters.

Depiction of a committee room in the House of Commons, showing the committee on the Chatham election petition. There are several men in lawyers' wigs standing with their backs to the viewer, and several men sitting around a horseshoe-shaped table. The room has decorative wallpaper and wooden panelling.
Committee of the House of Commons upon the Chatham election (Illustrated London News, 12 Mar. 1853, author’s scan from an original image)

Unlike other select committees, where the MPs on the committee asked questions of the witnesses who were called to give evidence, in election petitions it was the lawyers on either side who presented their case in a similar format to a legal trial, questioning and cross-examining witnesses. The committee members made only occasional interventions to clarify details.

Although the revelations of bribery, treating and other misdemeanours presented in their reports make for a fascinating read, for the MPs sitting on these committees, the process could be extremely dull, with trials sometimes dragging on for weeks. Reporting in 1848 that the members of the committee on the Cheltenham petition had decided to adjourn to attend the Epsom Derby horse race, the Morning Post praised those serving on the Leicester election committee, who had ‘resisted the allurements of Epsom Downs, and manfully sat out the dry law arguments, which occupied the whole day’.

There were several possible outcomes for an election petition.

  • The petition was withdrawn before the process of appointing a select committee began. Over 43% of the petitions presented during this period did not make it as far as a trial.
  • The petitioners sometimes abandoned the case during the trial, either because it became apparent that they did not have sufficient evidence to prove their allegations of corruption, or because of a behind-the-scenes compromise. These compromises often involved the ‘pairing’ of petitions: the Conservatives would withdraw a petition against a Liberal in exchange for the Liberals dropping a petition against a Conservative. The election of the sitting MP (or MPs) would therefore be confirmed by the committee.
  • The committee could decide that the allegations of corruption or other charges had not been proven and declare the MP (or MPs) who had been petitioned against to be ‘duly elected’, confirming their return to the Commons. Of the 424 petitions which made it to trial during this period, more than half (54%) confirmed the existing election outcome.
  • The MP could be unseated and one of the defeated candidates seated in their place. In such cases, which usually involved contests where the margin of victory had been small, the defeated candidate had to have claimed the seat and could face retaliatory charges of corruption on their own side. The committee would undertake a scrutiny of the poll, striking off the ‘bad votes’ of those who had not been qualified to vote. There were various grounds on which voters could be disqualified. These included having taken a bribe, received ‘poor relief’ (financial support under the poor law) or having moved away from the property for which they claimed the vote. When sufficient votes had been struck off from the total of the unseated MP, the defeated candidate would be declared duly elected in his place. Sixty-seven of the petitions tried during this period (16%) replaced victorious MPs with defeated candidates.
  • The entire election could be declared ‘void’, unseating the MP or MPs. This was the outcome in 30% of the cases which came to trial and was usually followed by a by-election in the constituency, although this did not always take place immediately.  Gloucester and Wakefield, whose MPs were unseated on grounds of corruption after the 1859 election, both had to wait until February 1862 for by-elections to fill their vacant seats, effectively being punished for the corruption of the voters. There were complaints in Wakefield that its temporary disfranchisement had caused ‘stagnation of trade… loss of commercial status, and depreciation of the value of property’. MPs who had been unseated for corruption could not stand at the ensuing by-election.

The system of election petitions underwent a substantial change in 1868, when the Commons transferred jurisdiction from its own select committees to election judges, who tried election petitions in the constituency.

KR

Key legislation:

1828 Controverted Elections Act

1839 Election Petitions Act

1844 Controverted Elections Act

1854 Corrupt Practices Prevention Act

1868 Election Petitions Act


Discover more from The History of Parliament

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Author

Kathryn Rix

Kathryn Rix is a historian of modern Britain, specialising in electoral and parliamentary politics in the long nineteenth century. She is Co-editor of the House of Commons 1832-1945 section.

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.