A traitor in their midst: Thomas Wrangwysshe and the 1489 attack on York


In 1489, a rebellion broke out in Yorkshire, sparked by Henry VI’s attempts to raise unpopular taxes. Despite being short lived, as Dr Jonathan Mackman explores, the rebellion had major implications for the city of York and its local officials.

On 28 April 1489, Henry Percy, 4th earl of Northumberland, was killed at South Kilvington, near Thirsk, while negotiating with rebels protesting against the collection of taxes to fund Henry VII’s proposed expedition to Brittany. The earl’s death sent shockwaves through the ruling classes. While the rebels initially dispersed, they soon reformed under a new leader, Sir John Egremont, and after first marching south towards Doncaster, they soon turned around and headed instead for the centre of royal power in the north, the city of York.

Panoramic watercolour of York in the 15th century.
York in the 15th Century by Edwin Risdale Tate (1914). Accessed via Wikimedia Commons.

The authorities in York found themselves in a difficult position. Firm supporters of the old Yorkist monarchy, the citizens had since reconciled themselves to the new Tudor regime, but were now trapped between a royal government for which many still bore only lukewarm loyalty and a rebel force feared for the potential damage and destruction it might bring. The day after the earl’s death, the mayor ordered his fellow councillors to remain in the city and await the King’s instructions, and also sent scouts out into the surrounding countryside and readied the city’s defences. The council was doubtless aware that the rebels were far closer than any relieving royal army, and would have been keen to avoid the fate of St. Albans, whose streets had twice seen fighting during the Wars of the Roses.

This attempt to avoid confrontation and buy time soon failed, and on 15 May the rebel forces broke into the city. Despite the fears, there is little evidence that they caused significant damage beyond the initial assault, and they did not stay long, soon heading northwards. On 17 May, during the withdrawal, a priest sent by Egremont asked the city council to supply 20 horsemen to join his force, stating menacingly that if they did not ‘thai wold answer to hym at ther iuperdie’ . The council, fearful that the rebels would rob the city if they refused, reluctantly agreed, but the imminent arrival of the royal force prompted most of the rebels to disperse as they withdrew, and the rebellion quickly dissipated without further conflict. For York the danger was over, but the investigations and recriminations soon began. The King himself arrived on 23 May, and four days later established a judicial commission led by four earls, his uncle Viscount Welles, the two chief justices and numerous others. Hearings soon began in the York Guildhall, but while a number of people were indicted for their involvement, including the fugitive Egremont, the most shocking revelation for the civic authorities must have been the participation of one of their own number, alderman and former mayor Thomas Wrangwysshe.

Photograph of York Guildhall from the river.
York Guidlhall, 2023. Accessed via Wikimedia Commons.

Wrangwysshe had been a hugely influential member of York’s establishment for almost three decades. He had served as chamberlain in 1463-4 and as sheriff in 1466-7, been elevated to alderman by at least 1470, and had twice served as the city’s mayor, in 1476-7 and again in 1484-5. He was also a key figure in the York Mercers’ Company, acting as its master between 1471 and 1473, and had long been one of the city’s most prominent councillors. He had been one of the key supporters there of Richard of Gloucester, later Richard III, and when Gloucester wrote to York in June 1483 requesting military assistance against Queen Elizabeth and her supporters, the council sent a force of 200 horsemen under Wrangwysshe’s leadership. His position also made him an obvious candidate to represent the city in Parliament, and he was elected on four separate occasions. He first sat in Edward IV’s extended Parliament of 1472-5, and was chosen again in the spring of 1483 to sit in Edward V’s ultimately aborted Parliament, and that autumn, in the assembly summoned under Richard III’s seal, which fell victim to Buckingham’s uprising. He was finally able to take his seat in what was in the event to be Richard III’s only Parliament in the early weeks of 1484.

Despite his Yorkist credentials, Wrangwysshe had ostensibly transitioned to the new political reality. He had remained an active councillor through the first years of Henry VII’s reign, and as such had participated in almost all the major council decisions, including those made at the height of the rebel threat. However, according to an indictment taken on Friday 29 May, on 12 May Wrangwysshe had ordered certain people from nearby Acomb (where he almost certainly held property) to supply two armed men to be sent to join Egremont and his fellow ‘traitors and rebels’. The Acomb men had claimed that they were unable to do this, so instead Wrangwysshe sent two of his own men to them the following day, and ordered the villagers to pay their wages to join the rebels. Again, the villagers refused. These events had taken place in the days immediately before the rebel force entered York, and well before the meeting of 17 May where the council agreed to appease Egremont’s envoy. The clear implication therefore was that Wrangwysshe had done this of his own accord, in treasonous support of the rebels.

On Monday 1 June the city sheriffs were ordered to have jurors at the Guildhall by 9am the following morning, the writ stipulating that these should have no connection with Wrangwysshe or his fellow accused William Lister. This requirement, probably a difficult one to meet, was seemingly ignored, given that the 31 names returned by the sheriffs included no fewer than four of Wrangwysshe’s fellow aldermen, all of whom were selected as jurors – William Snawsell (MP for York in 1470), Nicholas Lancaster and John Gilyot (MPs in 1487) and William White (MP in 1495). Whether or not these men were particularly close to Wrangwysshe is unclear, but if Wrangwysshe hoped their presence would assist him he was mistaken. He was found guilty, and his lands and goods in the city were immediately seized. However, this was only part of Wrangwysshe’s crimes. A further indictment noted how Egremont and his supposedly 5,000-strong rebel force had entered the city on 15 May after attacking and burning the city gates at Walmgate and Fishergate, both of which had been insufficiently repaired and armed through the negligence of their warden – none other than Wrangwysshe himself – and while the indictment only accused him of negligence, the charges certainly imply that he was complicit in the rebels’ entry into the city. Again, he was found guilty.

Etching of the ruins of Walmgate Bar, York, before its restoration.
Walmgate Bar, York by R. Sande (1814). Accessed via Wikimedia Commons.

Despite the verdicts and the threat of imminent execution, Wrangwysshe escaped serious punishment, and on 9 July he secured a general pardon. Relatively few men were indicted for their involvement in the rebellion, and only a handful were executed, no doubt a reflection of the King’s desire to pacify the region as quickly as possible. Yet Wrangwysshe’s career in York was effectively over. He was not officially replaced on the council until January 1490, by which time he may well have died, but he is not known to have attended any further council meetings or to have participated in city affairs after his conviction. He was buried in the now-demolished church of St. Crux, Pavement, alongside his first wife Alison, but despite his dramatic fall, his reputation in York seemingly survived. His younger son Richard was later admitted to the freedom as the son of ‘Thomas Wrangwysshe, merchant and former alderman’, and when his elder son William became the city’s mace-bearer in 1500, this was explicitly on account of his father having twice served as mayor. Despite his actions during the events of 1489, Wrangwysshe had clearly retained a degree of respect from his fellow citizens, and his long career at the head of York’s administration was a memory the city was unwilling to forget.

Further Reading

The York House Books, 1461-1490, ed. L.C. Attreed (2 vols, Stroud, 1991).

M.J. Bennett, ‘Henry VII and the Northern Rising of 1489’, English Historical Review, 105 (1990), pp. 34-59.


Discover more from The History of Parliament

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Jonathan Mackman is a Medieval historian, with interests including political, administrative and legal history, as well as local and regional history. He is a Research Fellow in the House of Commons 1461-1504 section.

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.